Sinful Threesomes Recipe - or, if you must, Toffee Bars

Years ago I discovered a toffee bar recipe and instantly fell in love.  Back then, we referred to them as ‘squares’.  Today?  We call them Sinful Threesomes.

It wasn’t until a few years later that these beauties earned their moniker.

At the time I lived in quaint duplex with poor heating and a terrible layout.  I loved that apartment and it holds many dear memories.  It was a cold winter, I had no cable (I was broke…) and the storm meant my ‘high speed’ internet was on the fritz… again.  So I bribed the guys downstairs with some baking in exchange for tube time.  American Idol was in full swing and week after week I would produce yummy goodness for my bachelor friends who put up with my girly shows for an evening a week.

The first time I brought down my squares the boys looked suspicious.  ‘Come on, have one.  I guarantee you won’t regret it’ I said.  Finally someone grabbed a piece and shoved it in his mouth.

OHMERGOOD!‘ he said.  After much groaning and chewing he swallowed the last few crumbs and turned to his posse.

‘OMG that felt like 3 layers of sin were having sex in my mouth!!!’.  

And so, Sinful Threesomes were born.  Enjoy, you can thank me later!

If you decide to test this Sinful Threesomes recipe, tell me about your results in the comments below!

 Sinful Threesomes Recipe by Angele @Shoeboxbegone

A few tips

You don’t *have* to melt the butter in step 1, but it makes the cookie layer more fluffy and easier to spread in the pan.  Also, you can substitute margarine if you wish, but the resulting texture will be different.

Your step 2 mixture should have the consistency of warmed putty; same for your chocolate layer.

This time I added a 1/4 tsp peppermint extract in both the toffee and chocolate layer.  Feel free to experiment!

Want More Funnies?

Enter your email address to receive notifications of new posts by email.

< Previous | Next >
%d bloggers like this: